Let’s Make History With the “Women’s Division”
August 5, 2020
During one of the first virtual Convocations of Summer Phase on July 8, 2020, Headmaster Fr. Edwin Leahy ‘63, O.S.B., questioned whether the titles “boys” and “girls” are appropriate. He then prompted the community to decide whether we should propose a new name for both divisions. This inaugurated a thought. Finally, I would have the opportunity to be referred to as what I really am. I propose that we rename the Girls Division as Benedict’s “Women’s Division.”
As a young woman, I am aware that the terms “girl” and “woman” are simply used to distinguish gender and age difference. In extreme cases, however, the terms can be seen to be condescending. So much is expected of us at present. Our families, teachers, and communities have high expectations that we must handle a multitude of challenges, from academics and sports to activities. We are expected to run the school and lead by example. These are not the expectations of someone who is a girl. It almost seems unfair to refer to us as girls in light of the great promise some perceive in us. Believe it or not, we are going to live up to these expectations, regardless of those who have little faith in us. Do what is right and give us the name commensurate with those high standards set for us.
I am not what society says I am. Because I am not yet eighteen, I am technically a girl. Girls are children and children by nature are immature and fragile. I have long outgrown those characteristics. I am far closer to being a woman than a girl. My actions and principles define me far better than these vague terms. In fact, as a pioneer of the “Girls” Prep Division, I propose the use of a new definition for the word woman. A woman is a female who acts with dignity, respect, and honor towards herself and others. She is someone who learns from her own experiences, leads by example, and is not afraid to admit her faults. Consequently, one does not merely become a woman but learns how to be one.
With this new way of thinking about the word woman, I am not arguing that teenagers are full adults. What I am saying is that we are women at heart. We are women through our actions, in how we treat others, and in the respect we give to our Sisters.
Now you may be asking yourself, what exactly does that look like ? Well, it looks like someone who is persistent, not a quitter; someone, as The Benedict Man’s Chant says, who “acts with dignity, respect and honor” towards herself and others and most importantly someone who “respects all walks of life.” In other words, we are Benedict’s Women. We carry our name within the SBP community and society with dignity, respect and humility.
Glenn Cassidy • Sep 3, 2020 at 12:13 pm
Several weeks ago Yoangil Nolasco and William Register wrote pieces arguing to change the names of the Prep Divisions from Boy’s and Girl’s to Men’s and Women’s. I’d like to start by thanking them for starting a very important conversation. Their pieces quickly received wide-spread praise – as they should have – and inspired some people to adopt the Men’s and Women’s titles without further reflection or discussion. I, however, was more compelled to eliminate the Boys and Girls names than I was to adopt the Men’s and Women’s names. I’d like to offer my reasoning and a different suggestion.
Mr. Register says that “Since we first stepped on the property as freshmen, we have been referred to as Benedict’s Men.” I would challenge that assertion. Since you first arrived you’ve been challenged to “aspire to be a Benedict’s Man”. At graduation, we hear the class for the first time say “I have become a Benedict’s Man”. This is an important distinction and not one that we should gloss over too easily. As we work to make our mottos and songs more inclusive, I trust that there will be an equivalent of this motto for the girls so that at graduation they can emphatically say “I have become a Benedict’s Woman”.
Ms. Nolasco states that students are “expected to run the school and lead by example. These are not the expectations of someone who is a girl…we are going to live up to these expectations.” These points are well taken. However, “going to” refers to what is coming, not what has been done. The title of Men and Women, I believe, implies that we have attained a certain standing in life (even if that standing is defined by age.)
St. Benedict’s has become well-known for the rites of passage that students must complete to earn their next title, uniform, or standing in the school. It is for this reason that we require students to complete the overnight, earn their colors, complete the trail, get drafted into groups, and more. Graduation from the school is one of those rites of passage and with it comes the title Benedict’s Men and Women. Changing our division names to Men’s and Women’s minimizes the need to earn this title.
Therefore, I am proposing that we avoid the temptation to follow traditional societal names and use the Benedict’s creativity to determine new names for the divisions. As we have with so many other things, let us create our own language. We could use any number of naming paradigms. Since we already use colors and people’s names for so many things, I would suggest avoiding those. Perhaps a naming committee could be developed to collect suggestions – from students, faculty, alumni, and others – collate those suggestions, and then prepare a report or vote for the community. I’d be happy to help.
Char-Lotte Searcy • Aug 13, 2020 at 7:16 pm
Resolved: A good debater never deviates from the topic. She knows the topic thoroughly and has the ability to clearly place points and express concrete sentiment. WELL DONE YOHANGIL!
michael falivena SPB'59 • Aug 9, 2020 at 10:22 pm
I agree. “Women’s Division”
Renata Rafferty • Aug 9, 2020 at 5:25 pm
Brilliant!
Jeff • Aug 7, 2020 at 3:41 pm
Hello,
Icame to the essay with opinion that the two divisions should be “Boys” and “Girls.”
I feel the real transition from youth to adulthood is having to make a regular payment ie car, rent, mortgage etc…
But I find my mind changed. Effective writing.
Coming from a fully grown adult, please be cautious. If you and your fellow young scholars want to be regarded as Women or Men, be prepared to put away childish things. (1 Cor 13:11).
Forgot this, lost that….those are childish things. Adult world does not care enough about you to correct you. Adult world finds somebody else.
I admire your wisdom to realize that this is more than semantics. You are setting a high level of expectation for yourselves.
Sincerely,
Jeff
April Torres • Aug 7, 2020 at 9:34 am
Beautifully written. Future advocate of people.
Didier Jean-Baptiste • Aug 6, 2020 at 1:28 pm
Well argued, Yohangil. My ageist side keeps wanting to add the word “Young” in front of “Women’s” and “Men’s,” perhaps to make a distinction between students and teachers. But I think I have to let go of that way of thinking. First, practically, “Young Women’s Division” is too long, and second, your point that you are women in formation, just as we older men and women (teachers) remain imperfect men and women who are also continuing to evolve, strikes a chord with me.